Mafia The Old Country is one of the most captivating games of 2025. Old Country‘s tense social dynamics, immersive storytelling, and constant thrill of deception and deduction capture the exact appeal of the Mafia franchise. The Old Country’s unique blend of strategy, suspicion, and role-playing, as well as the beautiful in-game scenery and graphics, makes it an incredible gaming experience. If you are in search of other games with a similar feel to Mafia The Old Country, this list has you covered. Here are ten of the best games to play if you are looking for that same mix of betrayal, alliances, and captivating stories.
Table of Contents
L.A. Noire (2011)
Platform: PC, PS3/PS4, Xbox 360/One, Switch
L.A. Noire offers a richly atmospheric period experience, set in 1940s Los Angeles, much like The Old Country, albeit on the other side of the law. In this L.A. Noire, you investigate murders, interrogate suspects using facial animation tech, and uncover corruption within the LAPD. Like The Old Country, Noire‘s methodical, stylish, and narrative-heavy. It focuses less on gunplay and more on storytelling, moral complexity, and atmosphere. L.A. Noire is a great period piece well ahead of its time.
Empire of Sin (2020)
Platform: PC, PS4, Xbox One, Switch
Empire of Sin is set in Prohibition-era Chicago, where you play as one of several crime bosses vying for control over the city. The game features management systems for running speakeasies, brothels, and casinos, as well as turn-based tactical combat when diplomacy fails. While Empire of Sin is not a third-person action game, it shares The Old Country‘s deep immersion in historical organized crime.
Note: Affiliate Disclosure: At PlayRatedGames, our content is made possible by our readers. If you purchase a game or product through links on our site, we may receive a small commission. This support helps us continue publishing honest, independent reviews. Our recommendations are based solely on what we believe offers real value to players — never influenced by affiliate partnerships.
Yakuza 0 (2015)
Platform: PC, PS4/PS5, Xbox
Yakuza 0, the prequel to the Yakuza series, introduces two protagonists who must navigate the neon-soaked criminal underworld of 1980s Japan. Yakuza 0 mirrors The Old Country with its highly cinematic long-form storytelling, dramatic character arcs, and intense combat system. The game emphasizes themes like loyalty, betrayal, and the burden of leadership, very much in the spirit of The Old Country. However, it is less about gunplay and more about grounded, character-focused action and heavy drama.
Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days (2010)
Platform: PC, PS3, Xbox 360
Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days is a raw, chaotic, and gritty crime shooter that follows two broken men caught in the underbelly of Shanghai’s criminal world. The game uses a unique, shaky, camcorder-style aesthetic to immerse you in its brutal, fast-paced gunfights and desperate tone. While not quite as structured or story-deep as The Old Country, it nails the feeling of Enzo and Isabella Torrisi being trapped in a violent world with no way out.
Omerta: City of Gangsters (2006)
Platform: PC, Xbox 360
Omerta: City of Gangsters is a mob strategy game set in the Prohibition era. The game focuses on building up a small-time operation in 1920s Atlantic City. Combat takes place in turn-based missions with tactical depth. Ormeta is perfect for players who want the historical mafia vibe of The Old Country, with emphasis on brains and tactics rather than bullets and blades.
Scarface: The World Is Yours (2006)
Platform: PS2, Xbox, PC, Wii
Scarface: The World Is Yours is a what-if scenario that explores an alternate story where Tony Montana survives and vows to rebuild his drug empire. Set in 1980s Miami, the game features brutal gunfights, empire-building mechanics, and an over-the-top yet driven protagonist. Scarface offers the kind of gritty rise-to-power arc that fans of The Old Country will enjoy.
The Godfather II (2009)
Platform: PC, PS3, Xbox 360
Set in the 1960s, The Godfather II offers cinematic storytelling and strategic gameplay similar to Mafia: The Old Country. You play as a rising mob boss expanding the Corleone family’s reach across cities like New York, Miami, and Havana. The game combines third-person shooting with a unique Don’s View, where you manage businesses, assign lieutenants, and plan hits. Its family loyalty, brutal executions, and historical vibe mirror the tension and ambition of Mafia: The Old Country.
The Godfather: The Game (2006)
Platform: PS2, Xbox, PC, Xbox 360, PS3
This game blends iconic moments from the Godfather film with an original story. You play as Aldo Trapani, an up-and-coming enforcer working for the Corleone family. The game’s mission structure, open-world crime sandbox, and respect for source material make it a rich experience for fans of mafia epics. Aldo Trapani’s story and rise through the ranks somewhat mirror Enzo’s rise in the Torrisi family, as both stories heavily feature themes of legacy, respect, and making your bones in a brutal world.
Sleeping Dogs (2012)
Platform: PC, PS3/PS4, Xbox 360/One
You play as Wei Shen, an undercover cop in the Hong Kong Triad underworld. Like The Old Country, Sleeping Dogs blends an immersive urban setting with a compelling personal story of dual identity and torn loyalties. The game features strong melee combat, cinematic missions, and a balance of action, story, and emotional stakes. The cultural detail and gritty realism add to its appeal for fans of grounded crime dramas. Sleeping Dogs’ Wei Shen and Old Country’s Enzo share a lot of similarities in their stories, character arcs, and internal conflicts.
Red Dead Redemption 2 (2018)
Platform: PC, PS4, Xbox One
While a Western on the surface, Red Dead Redemption 2 is fundamentally about loyalty, survival, and the inevitable decline of a way of life, much like The Old Country. You play as Arthur Morgan, a loyal but weary enforcer in a dying gang. The game combines cinematic storytelling, period authenticity, and moral ambiguity, all delivered with incredible polish.
If you connected with the emotional weight and historical tone of Mafia: The Old Country, RDR2 will feel like a natural progression. Similarly, both games also impress greatly in terms of gameplay and graphic elements. Featuring horse and vehicle chases, epic gunfights with weapons from a time long gone, incredible close combat scenarios, and beautiful scenery. These two games are so closely similar that they may as well be from the same series. So if you are looking to fill that Mafia: The Old Country-shaped hole in your life but not quite ready to dive into a second playthrough, you should definitely jump into RDR2.
Watch Mikhail explore the OG life of crime in early 1900s Sicily. Hit like/subscribe for more :))
