College Football 26: Highest Rated Defensive Players in the game

For defensive players, College Football 26 brings an extra level of realism, whether you’re locking down receivers as a shutdown corner, disrupting plays as a dominant edge rusher, or anchoring the defense at linebacker. Player ratings are at the core of the experience, reflecting each athlete’s skill, impact, and style of play.

While the game is filled with talented defenders, only a select few stand out as truly elite. So who are the game’s most dominant forces on defense? Check out our list of the highest-rated defensive players in College Football 26 and see who made the cut.

College Football 26 Best Defensive Players

Dillon Thienman

Dillon Thienman is an impressive strong safety for Oregon in College Football 26, holding a solid 93 overall rating. Standing at 6’0″ with great speed and instincts, Thienman is a versatile defender who can cover ground quickly and make pivotal plays in the secondary. Just shy of the elite tier, he’s a crucial piece of Oregon’s defense and a valuable asset for any Dynasty Mode coaches looking to bolster their secondary with a reliable playmaker.

Note: Affiliate Disclosure: At PlayRatedGames, our content is made possible by our readers. If you purchase a game or product through links on our site, we may receive a small commission. This support helps us continue publishing honest, independent reviews. Our recommendations are based solely on what we believe offers real value to players — never influenced by affiliate partnerships.

Thienman shines with his comprehensive defensive skill set. He boasts a 93 Pursuit, paired with 85 Man Coverage and 89 Hit Power, making him a threat both in coverage and against the run. His 91 Awareness allows him to read offenses quickly and anticipate plays, while a 92 Acceleration and 91 Speed help him close on ball carriers or receivers with ease. Additionally, his 85 Tackling and 95 Stamina ensure he can deliver impactful hits and stay active throughout the game.

David Bailey

Texas Tech’s David Bailey is a standout Left Edge with an impressive 93 overall rating. At 6’3″, Bailey combines explosive power and quickness off the edge, making him one of the most disruptive pass rushers in the game. Bailey serves as a critical force in Texas Tech’s defensive front and a key player for any Dynasty Mode player looking to build a relentless defensive line.

Bailey excels with a dominant pass-rushing skill set. His 75 Block Shedding rating may not be at the elite level, but his 87 Power Moves and 95 Finesse Moves allow him to consistently beat offensive linemen. His 89 Hit Power and 83 Tackling make him a threat against the run, while a 91 Acceleration and 85 Speed ensure he can chase down quarterbacks and ball carriers with impressive quickness.

Colin Simmons

93-rated Right Edge Colin Simmons starts as a sophomore on the Texas roster. Simmons shines in defense due to his elite coverage skills. He boasts a whopping 98 Pursuit rating and a 92 Hit Power, making him a danger to any ball carriers. His 87 Play Recognition helps him anticipate routes and make timely breaks on the ball, while his 90 Speed and 95 Acceleration enable him to keep up with the fastest receivers.

Chandler Rivers

Chandler Rivers is a standout Cornerback for Duke in College Football 26, carrying a strong 93 overall rating. Rivers stands out with a balanced defensive skill set, but gives the most benefit in defense when he’s chasing down ball carriers. He boasts a 92 Speed, along with 95 Acceleration and 95 Stamina, enabling him to close down opposing players on the ball quickly to deliver crunching tackles from whistle to whistle throughout the game.

Peter Woods

Peter Woods is a junior defensive tackle for Clemson in College Football 26, boasting an incredible 94 overall rating. Woods combines strength and technique to anchor Clemson’s defensive line.

Woods excels in clogging running lanes and putting pressure up the middle. He features a 95 Block Shedding rating and 91 Power Moves, allowing him to overpower offensive linemen and disrupt plays in the backfield. His 88 Tackling and 92 Hit Power make him effective at stopping runs, while his massive 94 Strength ensures he can hold his ground against double teams. Complemented by 88 Awareness and 84 Stamina, Woods stays engaged and consistently impacts the line of scrimmage throughout the game.

Jermod McCoy

Jermod McCoy is Tennessee’s 94-rated star Cornerback. McCoy is best utilized in dynamic pass-rushing scenarios and run defense. He boasts a 94 Zone Coverage rating, paired with 91 Play Recognition and 88 Press, allowing him to react sharply to plays and beat blockers with a variety of techniques. His 95 Acceleration and 91 Speed enable him to quickly close gaps and chase down quarterbacks.

Dylan Stewart

Dylan Stewart is a 94-rated Right Edge who plays for South Carolina in College Football 26. Stewart’s 99 Pursuit rating alongside 96 Finesse Moves, 83 Tackling, and 93 Hit Power make him effective against a variety of running schemes. With incredible Acceleration (96) and Speed (91) stats, Stewart has the agility to cover ground quickly and close in on ball carriers.

T.J. Parker

T.J. Parker’s 95 overall rating makes him one of the most incredible Left Edges in the game. Some of his best defensive stats include 97 Power Moves, 97 Pursuit, 97 Play Recognition, and 94 Hit Power. He also boasts 95 Awareness, 95 Injury Resistance, and 94 Toughness, making him one of the most unstoppable forces in any defense in CFB 26.

Anthony Hill Jr.

Hill Jr. excels in both run-stopping and pass rushing. He boasts an 85 Block Shedding rating and 79 Power Moves, allowing him to overpower offensive linemen and penetrate the backfield. His 93 Tackling and 97 Hit Power are where his real talents lie, as they make him a formidable run defender, while his 84 Strength ensures he can hold his ground against double teams. Complemented by 90 Awareness and 92 Stamina, Hill Jr. stays active and effective throughout the entire game.

Caleb Downs

Ohio State’s Caleb Downs is the highest-rated defender in College Football 26 with an overall rating of 96. He features an 85 Zone Coverage rating and 87 Man Coverage, allowing him to effectively cover receivers across the field. His 84 Tackling and 94 Hit Power make him a physical presence in run support, while 85 Awareness helps him quickly diagnose plays and react accordingly. With 95 Acceleration and 93 Speed, Downs can close ground quickly and stay on top of receivers. His massive 98 Stamina ensures he remains a consistent force throughout the game.

Whether you’re controlling Ohio State or building a defense in Dynasty Mode, Downs is the kind of safety who can patrol the back end, deliver solid tackling, and make plays that keep your defense one step ahead.